Sealion Projects

Goodhart's Guild

Pick one number to track each week and watch twelve guild members game it.

game ยท phone-firstTwelve weeks, about three minutesPublished 23 Oct 2026managementincentivesgame-designmetrics

Playable game

Designer's notes

The rule

You run a guild of twelve members for twelve weeks. Each week you pick one number to put on the public board: hours online, damage, loot, helpfulness votes or clean-run score, or you can pick nothing. Members with a strong gaming streak chase the number at the cost of the other four jobs. At the end a survey scores the guild across all five. Stay above the win line and you keep the guild; chase one number for twelve weeks and you will not.

What's new about it

Management games usually reward the number they show you. Here the shown number always goes up, and that is the trap. Each member has a ring for the board and a core for what they really did, and the weekly report opens the gap between them. It came from a game-design thread on how to measure contribution without the measurement becoming the goal: the game is that argument made playable, including the way a metric left alone for weeks gets learned and gamed harder.

Who'll love it

Players who like Papers, Please, Democracy or Reigns, where a small set of levers shows you the side effects of your own policy. Designers and team leads who have watched a dashboard go wrong will recognise every quip in the report. It is not for players who want action, loot or a story, and it is not a management simulator with real staffing advice.

In this build

One mode: twelve simulated members, five numbers plus a no-scoreboard option, twelve weeks. The members follow hand-written rules with hidden traits that are different every run; there is no AI and no real guild. Your best final health, the number of runs, and which numbers you have seen break are saved in this browser only. No sound, no difficulty levels, no member-by-member management. It is turn-based, so there is no pause.

If it holds up

The first test is whether players start a second guild to try a different order of numbers. If they do, the honest options are a small premium price with more metrics and member archetypes, pay-what-you-want on itch.io, or a licence to a game-design course. Ads would undercut a game about bad incentives. It would spread as a link in game-design and management communities, where the argument already circulates.

A focused game prototype from Sealion Projects. Anything it saves stays in this browser, on this device.