The question
On 22 October 2026 Second Minister for Finance Jeffrey Siow was reported as saying that about 80% of Singaporeans get more in government benefits than they pay in taxes. Most people cannot check that against their own life, because benefits arrive as vouchers, rebates, subsidies and top-ups, never on one statement, while tax shows up in a few clear places. This page lets you set a household and drag it up the income ladder to see where its own taxes and benefits cross, and how that point compares with the 80% mark.
The numbers
Everything is a yearly estimate with a low, middle and high value. Income tax uses the IRAS resident rate table after employee CPF (20% up to a $96,000 yearly ceiling), $1,000 earned-income relief, $4,000 per child and $9,000 per senior at home. GST is 9% of the taxable share of spending, with the spending share and the 60% taxable share set editorially. Benefits: GST Voucher cash $850 per adult under $39,000 assessable income in an HDB flat, MediSave $150 to $450 per senior, U-Save at four times the January 2026 quarterly amount, Assurance Package and CDC ranges, and school subsidy of $7,000 to $11,300 per child from MOF's "over $180,000 by age 16". Percentiles use a log-normal curve around SingStat's 2025 median of $12,446 a month.
The comparison
The comparison is the break-even point: the income at which the net line crosses zero, drawn on the same ladder as the 20%, 50% and 80% marks of household income. Position beats a ratio here because the claim is about a share of people, so the useful question is where on the distribution a household of your shape stops being a net recipient. The percentile is read from the assumed curve, so it is approximate. The headline figure is the yearly net, with the range shown beside it so a single dollar value is never presented as exact.
What it leaves out
This is a model of one household shape and five benefit lines, not a test of the minister's claim, which covers a whole population and every benefit and tax. Left out: housing grants and CPF top-ups, one-off Budget payouts, Workfare, childcare, corporate and employer taxes, car and other duties, and the value of public goods. Singles, retirees living alone and non-citizens are not modelled. Healthcare subsidy, spending share and the spread of incomes are editorial placeholders. Published figures for the Assurance Package and CDC vouchers disagree between press summaries, so they carry wide ranges. The IRAS page fetched during the build was truncated, so the rate table was entered from the published schedule and should be re-checked.
Sources